RoseMary's manga / #Drama(852)

Mixed feelings about this story... I liked it for two reasons. Firstly, because it's an old manga, so I liked the whole old atmosphere, and, secondly, because it's a family affair story. And that's why I added this to my old-style romance and family affair lists. But I'll say that it was also a frustrating story for two other reasons. Well, first of all, as an avid BL reader, if I see a guy kissing another guy (and more than once at that!), I tend to automatically ship them, so the whole situation of Aoi and Sumire all along the story was frustrating for me, BUT, and from this I'll come then to the second reason, I actually found mysef liking Aoi and Yuri together so much, also because I didn't like Sumire much in the first place, so I was rooting for Aoi and Yuri instead! [Spoiler] But sadly they didn't end up together. I mean, no surprise there really, because they went for the obvious predictable course. It was obvious she would end up with Sumire...but I really liked Aoi and Yuri's interaction and moments all along the story, so I strongly hoped that they would end up together somehow! I don't care if they are half-siblings since it's a manga. I really think it would have been a more interesting outcome, if they ended up together. So, I can't really hide my disappointment about this. Anyway, having said all that, overall it's a good oldie, although I'm clearly not a fan of the couple... Adapted to Taiwanese Drama "The Rose" (2003)

The story is actually pretty good! Too bad for the issue of different art styles because that gives me the impression of a messy composition. That's a flaw for me and I resented it a bit. Other than that, I like the story! A sort of dramatic and melancholic mix, just how I like it! 2 Volumes (Complete) - Waiting for the last chapter and extras...

Ch. 45-46 their first kiss (Skyler kisses Yeonduk)

1 Volume (Complete) >> This is actually the first installment of a series of related stories. And it's the only one that is scanlated.

// Based on a Game, which also has an anime adaptation // - This manga version is an adaptation of the Sora's route, so the twincest one. > Personally, I really liked this! The setting was beautiful and, since I love this kind of setting, that's also what made me really like the story. Anyway, I think it was well-written. Well, maybe some details could have been done better, and in the end I guess I wanted to see a bit more of them, that's why I gave it 4 stars, but it was a very good manga to read with a very nice conclusion. And about the main theme, the twincest, it obviously depends on each person...as for me, I love to read this kind of stories because I love forbidden love themes, so I really liked it!

// Based on a Game and Light Novel series, which were also adapted into the famous BL anime // >> Well, it wasn't that bad, but it wasn't that good either. Because it felt like a draft. It was only a taste of the actual story. And, just about that, if one doesn't know the original story, for me it doesn't make much sense, it lacks a lot of background info. There are glimpses of their past, but it doesn't go much far into the actual story, let alone reaching the core plot. This remains at shounen ai level and basically this is almost entirely about them preparing for and doing a school play anyway. But, as I read then in the afterwards, it seems this adaptation came out when there wasn't much source material yet, so that could explain why there was so little to this. And it would also explain why the anime, which came out later, was very different. In any case, I prefer the anime. Altough it wasn't that great either for me, but it was certainly better than this.