![](https://pic1.mangapicgallery.com/r/avatar/9e/u322297_50x50.jpg?2)
╥﹏╥ Seeing them so happy makes my heart hurt so much because of what will happen. Why did that have to happen in chapter 46?!?!?!?!?
A part of me kinda wished that instead of Claude forgetting, Athanasia would be in a coma. Then we can see what Claude would think and how he would try to deal with the situation. That’d be interesting. But sadly that’s not how it works... :(
![](https://pic1.mangapicgallery.com/r/avatar/c7/u210050_50x50.jpg?2)
https://toonkor.land/무료웹툰 - so Claude saved her life and forgot her? Is that what happened? Σ(っ°Д °;)っ
![](https://pic1.mangapicgallery.com/r/avatar/c7/u210050_50x50.jpg?2)
Noooo(╯°Д °)╯╧╧ a ny more spoilers?? I am in love with spoilers, makes waiting a lot easier :D
SPOILER:
Saw in the comments below that Athy will run away from the castle and then Lucas will come back and make Claude remember Athy, but she will not be there anymore :( Not sure if its true though.(⊙…⊙ )
![](https://pic1.mangapicgallery.com/r/avatar/9e/u322297_50x50.jpg?2)
Spoiler:
i saw that everywhere too. That Claude will treat Athanasia like a fugitive and chasing her all over the country, while Jennette ends up becoming his daughter. I dont know if Lucas helps her to escape or helps Claude remember her. Honestly, I just want some daughter-father moments. I came here for that and now my heart is broken. : (
LMAO in those 3 months we have to wait. I'm gonna pull a Claude and forget this just so i don't have to hurt. OOOF WHY DID I SAY THAT ( ̄へ ̄)
![](https://pic1.mangapicgallery.com/r/avatar/9e/u322297_50x50.jpg?2)
So
The bow was suppose to kill Athanasia originally, but Claude managed to save her which lead him to losing his memories of her. Then remember the dream that Athanasia has about Jenette and Claude. Do you guys think that, that will happen in the future or is what happened in the novel to the original MC/Athanasia.
Another thing I’m interested about is what Jenette’s role will be after chapter 46. Because wouldn’t she feel guilty, that it’s her fault that her little sister almost died and that her “father” forgot Athanasia. Or will she take advantage of this and try to get closer to Claude with the help of her real father and Mr.White. I would also find it odd if Claude immediately accepts her as his daughter and love her more than Athanasia with Felix and the maid(s) there, telling him about their father-daughter relationship.
Or Jenette will just remain innocent and doesn’t know it’s the bow’s fault. Gets accepted as a daughter and Claude will love her. Causing Athanasia great grief and maybe running away with Lucas :)
![](https://pic1.mangapicgallery.com/r/avatar/e9/u305533_50x50.jpg?2)
I think that there might be a competition between these sisters but honestly Im fukkin sad about the ending of chapter 46. This webtoon is soooo good and I just want Athy to be happy with Claude.
And what I'm thinking is that Jenette doesn't realize that she is cursed like the visions of athys dream shows but i dont know haha
![](https://pic1.mangapicgallery.com/r/avatar/9e/u322297_50x50.jpg?2)
But just looking at Athy’s distraught face in Chapter 46. I feel like if Claude doesn’t remember her in the next few chapters. I have a feeling she’s gonna run away, because I dont think she can bear to hate Jennette since she’s innoncent.... GIRL I JUST WANT ATHANASIA AND CLAUDE TO BE HAPPY TOO!!! I NEED MORE OF THEIR PARENT-DAUGTHER MOMENTS!!!!! AknsosnskKkkmakmsn ╥﹏╥
![](https://pic1.mangapicgallery.com/r/avatar/60/u312968_50x50.jpg?2)
I agree with you! I guess the dream could be a premonition of what might happen in the future if Claude doesn't regain his memories ╥﹏╥
I just hope he will regainhis memories or Lucas will appear in the next few chapters to help Athy and Claude ╥﹏╥ Their relationship is just getting better i don't want it to be ruined just bc of that freakin' bow ╥﹏╥
![](https://pic1.mangapicgallery.com/r/avatar/9e/u322297_50x50.jpg?2)
So if you guys haven’t read ~Daugther of the Emperor~ or ~I am a child of this house~. Y’all should read them. They are pretty similar to this one . The daughter and father thing.
The Abandoned Empresse and Doctor Elise are also pretty interesting. ヾ(❀╹◡╹)ノ~
They’ll maybe help soother your anticipations. (Or make it worse)
![](https://pic1.mangapicgallery.com/r/avatar/9e/u322297_50x50.jpg?2)
So like....does anyone know what will happen after chapter 45?? Can someone spoil it to me, please?!!?!? (continue below)
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Since in the original Athanasia, Claude erases his memories of Athanasia. After chapter 45, will that happen again?? Because if it does, I’ll be so sad and I wouldn’t even be able to continue reading... T^T
![](https://pic1.mangapicgallery.com/r/avatar/40/u2299_50x50.jpg?2)
SPOILER
Claude didn't erase his memory of Athanasia, he erased his memory of Diana and thus didn't feel a connection to Athanasia when he met her the first time,cause by then he got rid of those memories. I'm guessing that since things will be different cause she has a relationship with him first that more things will just come to light? (his older brother, and jeannette) and Anthy will probably have to try to figure more things out now that they are getting to the point where the novel ended.
![](https://pic1.mangapicgallery.com/r/avatar/40/u2299_50x50.jpg?2)
Chapter 12 page 18 bottom panel claude talks about a year longer and he would have forgotten her face (he means diana) cause he was just thinking of her and him and felix were talking about athanasia looking like her.
End half of chapter 20 Claude thoughts about killing Athy when she got old enough/almost getting rid of all the memories of diana
And i thought there was another part where he talked about it or maybe it was an inference we made from that information but its logical to think thats why he didn't have an attachment to her in the book. Cause now when he looks at her, she reminds him sometimes of Diana but in the book she didnt cause he forgot about her
![](https://pic1.mangapicgallery.com/r/avatar/9e/u322297_50x50.jpg?2)
That’s why the next chapters will be interesting because Ijekiel’s (spelling?) father and assuming the other guy is Claude’s brother will try to get rid of Athanasia through Jenette (the blue bow) since their plans of introducing Jeanette as his daughter obviously won’t work. Since Claude also hasn’t forgotten Diana and instead further grew closer to Athanasia, it makes everything more complicated....We just have to see what troubles our MC will go through. I just want more Claude and Athanasia daughter and father moments. T^T
![](https://pic1.mangapicgallery.com/r/avatar/9e/u322297_50x50.jpg?2)
I like Jenette (sorry if the spelling is wrong) but I really don’t want her to ruin the father and daughter bond that Claude has with Athanasia right now. I feel really bad for Jenette because she thinks Claude is her father but actually it’s his brother who’s just using her (so far, maybe he loves her secretly. Lmao, tryna be optimistic) Also, so far, Lucas and Athanasia look better than Ijekiel and Athanisia.
ok sooooo...............before Dearest Claude lost his memory what was Athy's wish??????????
Spoilers COMING
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
..
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
....
.
.
.
.
.
I read a forum loooooooooong time ago and I THINK they said she wished for a...chair (some type of furniture)...? What do you guys think it could be? A painting of her and Claude? Either way, I think Lucas will use this to trigger Claude's memories of Athy. If the wish did get said, what was it? (Sorry I put this story for a while before continuing.....)
.
.
.
One other thing that I am thinking about is Jennette's mother. Does Jennette know her mother? Will the painting of Jennette's mother in Claude's room trigger a series of events (or were those discarded)? Will Claude adopt Jennette because of that? Can this be a way Jennette can get her wish?
.
.
.
I just really hope something will happen soon, because I feel really bad for Athy. At the same time I feel bad for Jennette because all she wants is a family. : (
Athy wished for the portrait!!!!!!! The portrait of athy and Claude together that was revealed right after he lost his memories. Like dude. Di you even paid attention to the story? ╮( ̄▽ ̄)╭(╯°Д °)╯╧╧
I just finished catching up today.....I put it off for sooooooooooooooooooo long cause I didn't wanna see Athy distraught. Yah... I'm a bad reader lmaoooo. Also I just found the chapter, where the painting was. : ( So sad Claude is treating Athy like this. It really hurts man. I came back for the good times, but came to the bad times.
I don't feel bad for Jeanette at all.. there's only so much naivety to excuse insensitivity that she's not really innocent at all
Couldnt agree more.
If only I could like this comment 100 times