isn't the creator busy with other projects? she probably doesn't have much time to work on Black Butler while having deadlines.
it is rather disappointing though, since we have to wait a month or so just for another short chapter that doesn't really say anything. I hope the ciel and sebastian arc will be rewarding. who knows, maybe she's writing ahead and working on those, and then putting her time in these chapters (just my wishful thinking)
seriously? and no one thought to tag mpreg? I got to chap 42 and suddenly had that thrown in my face?! I thought mandala blossom referred to, idk, like he satiates his madness?? Not, now you are pregnant??
question, why do ppl like mpreg? just read a hetero comic?
it's so gross to me, and I am NOT applying this to real people
real men having kids, woohoo, do what you want idc
why do you want to see this cis, fictional, weak man be impregnated by this macho muscle toxic boyfriend, have them grow tits and a baby belly, and then have the baby refer to the mc as mama? huh? disgusting, gross, get away from me
BARF, so fetishistic
get your breeding kinks away from me
immediate turn off
I was literally enjoying this manhwa so much, on the edge of my seat, wanting to see how they will somehow redeem the ML, but chapter 42 was where I had to stop. (I'm assuming he's pregnant bc ML was like, hmm he should be pregnant after this)
Unless someone tells me that the baby is aborted or the mc somehow neutralizes any present and future pregnancies, I will not be returning, LOL
hah? offended that I can state my own opinion? I have standards in BL, and this comic, despite me scouring beforehand, did not tell me it would be mpreg! thus I got pissed LOL
no one thinks this kind of stuff is mentionable beforehand, for some ungodly reason
I have the gall to comment that because it's still a story that has to follow a set of procedures, and from how it was going, I was hoping that the ML was acting all nice in chap 41 because he was turning a new leaf or something, I don't know, I'm not god!
I will write how I feel because I spent HOURS reading this, HOURS, only to be faced with fucking male pregnancy!
go ahead and be pissed on a public forum lololol, because I will too ٩(๑❛ᴗ❛๑)۶
sorry if I offended you, I guess? but that is my opinion, all the words I said, sorry if you felt dissed... (〜 ̄△ ̄)〜
and for your second comment, yeah... no one forced me to read this, I read this on my own volition... and got smacked in the face with mpreg...
since I chose to read this, I got extremely disappointed? thought, I'm leaving a comment, because how tf has no one else said anything about forced impregnation?
I don't know how to feel, at all
I'm just flabbergasted...
I genuinely don't know what I expected but it wasn't this,
while being incredibly well-written, I do feel that it was definitely bittersweet and, personally, would not reread lololol, my therapist will be hearing about you jesus
I guess, all in all, Jonathan just really wanted to be freed, really wanted to have somebody know him and surpass him, just so he could succumb to them, pay off his debts to Wald
Even now I don't know if J really loved Makoto. He released himself from the curse, and admitted to loving Makoto once. However, Makoto knew that it wasn't true, that he was never loved once by J
So are we supposed to take Makoto's word? I guess it makes the most sense, and Jonathan could have been trying to throw Makoto off?
I would have loved to see more of J's background? I feel like everything just happened, and while I definitely felt the tension, I wasn't truly able to feel, like, the emotion? is that dumb? the author def did an amazing job, but I didn't really develop an emotional connection to any of the characters beside Makoto and J, which could be mainly a me-problem
I don't know how I feel about Makoto taking in someone, much like how Wald took in J and J took in Makoto, it seems, just a little, contrived, in my opinion? After reading all of this and reaching the final chap. with him in the slums, I could just predict that, oh, he is probably trying to find someone like J that he can project himself on and hope that one day that boy will surpass him
Though, I do get it? Being that powerful can only last for so long, and you will always want for more. More being, destruction, something different, the end
I only know that that boy he picked up may be one of many, or the final key into ending his life
Will he join J in whatever twisted afterlife there is afterwards? Is there such a thing?
Truth be told, this artist inspires my art, I love just everything about it
I love this comment!! I think it's spot on, but i just wanted to add my perspective if you don't mind!
I don't think that M did look for another young demon to surpass him. J did it because he truly felt lonely and somewhat scared/apathic after Wald died, but Makoto never felt the need to be surpassed! J was in love with Wald and i feel like he also felt guilty about ending him, while M was just straight up obsessed with J.
Love, hate, respect, obsession: in the end the only thing he always ever strived to have was J in every form. J dying and cursing him was just another tie between them. To me, M went to the slums looking for someone bc that's what J did, rather than because he felt the need to. He did just what he was supposed to, following J footprints. Realizing it didn't bring him any closer to J had him down again, but Fjord was able to get him motivated again just by mentioning J (and he said so himself). Everything J did was because of true loneliness, everything M did was because of J!
It's a bittersweet ending, but i feel like it's also perfect, because we can see that M personality and true drive is still the same, the only thing that changed is the way he's trying to get closer to J.
Of course this is just the way i feel abt it and i may be completely wrong, but i loved your comment and just wanted to add my piece to it!! <3
Thank you for sharing, I finished it all last night and my head is reeling. I needed to read other people’s perspective, because there are sooooo many layers to this story to unpack.
I have a question for you though. What do you think Wald’s regret is? Why did his shade remain behind?
Also, Jonathan mentioned at what point if Makoto can “undo wald’s curse.”
Was Jonathan really hoping that Makoto would surpass himself? Or was he hoping that Makoto would only surpass Wald for Jonathan? make Jonathan forget about Wald and make jonathan love Makoto instead? Both scenarios would free Jonathan.
I think this story is about loss. Everybody lost. Wald, Jonathan and Makoto. Truly, love is a demon’s ruin, and we have not seen it reciprocated at all throughout. Even between Datenshou and S. Datenshou is in love with Jonathan, not S.
I find the theme ironic given the whole reason Makoto started this journey is that he wanted to be free from the world and his psychotic desires. It’s like even after all that character progression and plot, Makoto is back to square one. Nobody understood him but Jonathan, and Jonathan is now gone.
I love your thoughts,
and to answer your question,
I am also unsure... part of my unsure-ity stems from my forgetfulness lolol. I don't know if it's because I read the new chapters out in one go, or if it's because I haven't read any of the older chaps since around a year ago (happy new year!!) haha
Perhaps Wald felt regret for even picking the child, Jonathan, up from the streets, knowing it would only end wrongly, considering love for demons never ends well. I think Wald knew he would grow to love Jonathan, considering how overindulgent he was. I think that's also why he didn't want Jonathan to touch him, so the love wouldn't deepen
No demon wants to become weaker or "die," but demons, ironically, still depict humanly desires
Though, that was mostly what I was able to take from what I've read, what you think is probably more in depth... (づ ̄ ³ ̄)づ
What I think Jonathan subconsciously wanted was for someone to, somewhat, replace Wald
That's why he kept picking up little apprentices here and there, who subsequently failed.
When Makoto came, and demonstrated strength and perseverance, whose wish was to literally eat Jonathan, it peaked his interest
Finally, Jonathan thought, someone capable to... to what? I don't think Jonathan really knew himself
I agree with what you said, of how the story is about loss. But I also think it can also be about overcoming tribulations... while Jonathan suffered in the centuries Wald was gone, once he was faced with his past, because of the incense given to him by Makoto, he was able to grow stronger, in a way, he was able to break the curse and understand more, I think..............hmm...
Still not content with this, he waited for Makoto to become more powerful than him, and maybe because he felt he shouldn't go down too easily, he played around with Makoto after the 100 years had passed (ie breaking his horn and such)
Didn't Jonathan finally overcome everything, finally free himself from the underworld and his persistent guilt, once he uttered Makoto's name?
Makoto suffered, and still is suffering, but he is growing from it, and soon will, someday, be in Jonathan's position.
Love may be a demon's worse weakness, their undoing, but it is what also teaches them growth, considering their hedonistic tendencies
Really, I don't know... I think being a demon itself just guarantees pain and suffering, regardless of whether there is love or not
Maybe love acts as the catalyst in one's life and finally teaches them what their self-indulgent, gluttonous choices from before couldn't, that they can truly lose somebody
This story makes my head twirl, I only wonder how intelligent the author must be to conjure all of this up lol
But take what I've said with the tiniest granule of salt, I'm a little embarrassed as even I am unsure with my own thoughts and interpretations, hahahahahahaha
No no, I really appreciate hearing your take on it. this is seriously what keeps the story from being gratuitously violent: The many layers that are open to interpretation. I loved reading your take on it, as it’s almost like rereading the work in a new light. I think I’ll be revisiting this manga in a few months. I think the gore and depravity were mostly allegory: I keep returning to what Makoto said… how terribly human these demons were at their core.
Does anyone know where I can read a lot of the novel for free in English? I tried finding it, but the translated chapters aren't as far as where the manhwa is now... I was wondering if maybe there was some edited MTL or something?
Haha I had the novel opened as I read this, here you go:
https://readhive.org/series/44794/1.1/
bruh as "well written" this story is, or whatever, the author still heavily sexualizes Geom during the SA... Like, I want to see some grimaces, ugly contortions, subconsciously fighting back (ik it's been happening for years and he's used to it, but it's still... so, too, "well-drawn," and made him look all pretty and rendered with highlights and good lighting and whatnot),
I can't just read this story, watching a broken mc, not even be treated with respect by its own creator, the author
call me vanilla, tell me that people can read whatever they want, etc etc, still, this kind of shit is hard to read and, frankly, so lengthened for no reason...
I got to chap 18 and the whole time I was just screaming for Geom to just run away to another country or literally anythingggg, as impossible as it even sounds, obviously
thanks for the reply
I get that, (why I said "as impossible as it even sounds")
I just wish the author didn't, like, take literally any chance to draw Geom being r*ped and draw it so detailed, making him look all "aesthetically" broken as he moans.. fills me with disgust
Like, for instance, when Geom was being SA'd (mind you, I only got to chap 18 and haven't read further so lmk if I'm wrong), you got all the shots you do in regular smut, and when it was implied that he bled or something, you hardly saw the wound... why does the author value the penetration (ie the more "attractive" shots that are often displayed in BL) than the brutal pain that comes with it? Don't tell me about censorship and whatnot, if they can draw heavy smut, they can draw some blood and wounds, heaven knows the author doesn't care to drop trigger warnings either way
Also, I know that he staggers sometimes, and cries a lot
Obviously, I can just choose not to read it, but I feel like this kind of this is important to talk about
You don't wanna keep reading this lmao. I forgot which chapters but Geom's backstory was actually torture to read. The rape scenes just kept going. Every new chapter was another graphic display of Geom being raped or beaten. I was seriously concerned over the amount of time the artist must've spent drawing brutal rape scenes. Shouldn't they be sick of it by now?? We really don't need so many rape scenes drawn in graphic detail.
But you'll see Geom in anguish for sure. It was especially tough to get through because of how much you could see him suffering. I thought that I wouldn't be able to survive what he went through. I don't know how someone keeps their sanity after all that.
It's to hit home the cruelty of sexual slavery, and the confluence of high society and the criminal underworld. And just how blasé rape and sex slavery are to those who will do anything to have power.
Maybe it's too much for some readers to handle, but the author thinks it's appropriate to show just how cruelly he was treated, and the bullshit that he has to endure, and how his original anger eventually faded into apathy and despair.
After rereading your reply, no offense, but I don't think you got my point?
Part of my point was that the story wasn't showing how cruelly he was being treated by avoiding the wounds and blood, and continuously choosing to maintain his pretty, broken image
Geom is typically the main perspective, but we are only shown rape that comes with pretty highlights and submissive poses, tearing him down to his core, while making sure to point out the dick sliding in shot, and then him being left there like a used toy. Thus, I can accept that this is in the perspective of the assaulters and meant to depict part of the cruelty that comes with being in his situation
However, once alone, the story reverts back to his point of view. As a result, shouldn't it show the blood, the cuts, the UGLY crying, the moments alone where he idolizes suicide or something, the things no one wants to see because of how painful it is, now that he's not in the tangible grip of his captors? (again, I have read to only chap 18)
My whole point was that the reader is shown these awful moments, that, to me, almost feel like its romanticizing his pain by doing what all toxic BL does, which is minimizing the mc to a pretty, broken doll whose constantly raped to feel like he's worth nothing. I get that that's the whole point of this story, I get that he's a sex slave, being torn down, and being forced to accept the feelings of despair by not being able to run away, but, with how resilient he's been, shouldn't he be shown, by the author, that he is more than just that?
The author controls what's put in the story, they can easily add more painful, personal, moments, instead of opting for another sex scene that adds nothing to the story that most people would just prefer to skip because the message, about how awful rich, higher ups in the criminal underworld are, has already been established?
Maybe I'm just media-illiterate and too blind to see the underlying message, maybe I'm just too stubborn. sorry for writing an essay.
btw not attacking or trying to make you feel like I'm conceited or something, just replying with my opinion :(
show it to me rachel please rachel
Lmao