![](https://pic1.mangapicgallery.com/r/avatar/a0/u1632471_50x50.jpg?2)
I love how..Every Time..Every loop, He I meant Carcel, Finds his way back to Ines, and from the very beginning He loved Her just as much even in different loops. But because of how broken she is, she fails to see it or she denies it. ?
I don't know— i just loved how Loyal Carcel is to Ines.
![](https://pic1.mangapicgallery.com/r/avatar/6f/u3526655_50x50.jpg?2)
What that person said is a spoiler. He did marry her in the rl 1st life and he didn't cheat on her then. They both loved each other and she didn't manipulate him so he had always been loyal to her. That's his true self. Even in 2nd and 3rd life, he loved her and didn't marry bc of that so the only reason he cheated in this lifetime is bc she manipulated him to.
![](https://pic1.mangapicgallery.com/r/avatar/8b/u1557833_50x50.jpg?2)
POTENTIAL SPOILER
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Based on the comments I am assuming in the novel it wad revealed that iñez had not gone through 3 lives, but 4. The original one being with carcel but she had forgotten, which circles back to the fact that all this time Carcel had love her and only her regardless of her past or future because on her lives that she did not end up with him, he remained as a bachelor.
But this is based on speculation from the comments, so no guarantee nor an explanation how did her first life turn that way and following like so
....man oh man....i prefer Lucy to be with Savour tho....