He isn’t transgender
yes she is
Yeah he is
ok now you're just obviously being transphobic
Transphobic to a character that is clearly stated as he idc
they call her she and he. If we put the time period in. Transsexuals were called men then.
Even her child referring to J as a second mom. Ever manga is not gonna be loud with what they trying to say. Which I like. This story requires deeper comprehension based on the story. The nuances and the time period. If ya opinion that J is a guy. Thats your opinion. Im still gonna see it as a trans like story...even if J never goes through physical transistion. Since being transgender is not action but a state of being.
Dumbass she's literally says she's a women, stop denying your transphobia. You clearly misunderstood the story
Hes a boy
why are u reading a story about a trans woman while being transphobic , she's a women. The original japanese version didn't even use male pronouns, it's not a yaoi cry about it.
You’re telling me to cry about it yet replying to a 4 month post please cope
cope with the fact that j is a woman
cope with the fact that you get no bitches cuz ur stinky you transphobe
Hes a guy clearly stay mad
And you're a dumbass dipshit clearly stay mad
Cry more loser over a male fictional character
I'm starting to think that you just can't handle the fact that you've read a manga that wasn't yaoi/bl
and youre still replying to me why
because I can
What a fucking loser lol
J Is not androgynous. Her character is despeciable at times because she hates herself. She is slutty because she finds no worth in a body that doesn't fit HER. She is slutty because her father taught her, that was love. As a trans woman groomed as a child, this story hit to raw. This isn't like most mangas.
The story is told through context. Through the brilliantly constructed nuances
She fights with the idea of her transness and her fathers molestation juxtaposed. Her femininity that she plays with, she also feels dooms her. So she weaponized her looks and sexually appeal, getting what she wants, while feeling utterly lonely and unfulfilled
It's easy to write this off as a yaoi with a feminine male character, but it's not to me.
This is a darker transgender coming to womanhood story.
This story touched me in a way no other story touched me.
Its raw...gritty...real.
Honest in the confusion and torment, gender identity and learning it can bring.
We see her transistion from young gay androgynous guy to a cross dresser to a woman at the end, sitting next to her mom.
A woman and free from the trauma and shame that followed her. The trauma which stopped her from freeing herself. The lover who she loved but even then tried to kill herself.
Because she wasn't that young gay boy. She was a woman. She always was a woman. It's what pushed her to such drastic ways of self harm. It's why she tries to kill herself, even when the men she always loved brought her home.
This story...if you have a strong stomach is one of those most poignant trans stories I ever read .
This is a coming of age story of a trans woman chaser by the trauma of sexual assault/incest and ultimately free from it
Like any work of art, this story can take on multiple meanings, which I think is purposeful. Because we see the transition of J....it can be a presentation of a man binary person, a gay feminine male or a trans woman.
I think the end was kind blunted. The author could have elongated the end to give more meaning
But to me, her sitting in a dress is day time, not for work or play...tells me she accepted that she wanted womanhood