But its not low...
For what it is the rating is extremely high
Agree
Rattings on this site are horrible
I am wondering what your rating standards for mangas are? I find this website's rating fair though.
And once again I couldnt agree more.
Ppl here rate them incredibly high for only god knows what reason. Absolutely unorginal and incredibly average mangas have ratings 8 or higher... Sometimes mangas w/ absolutely no plot nor anything interesting nor anything outstanding also get scores 8 or above. I understand that ppl like them but its ridiculous...
I couldn't have said it better
An example I could give you of a way overrated manga is "Dos Obake Ga Nekasetekurenai"(the art is good,but that's about it).I've given high rattings in mangas like "yatamomo","escape journey".I also like "j no subete" etc.When it comes to manhwas "a guy like you","at the end of the road" are so overrated whereas "dark heaven" deserves the recognition.
I agree with you at everything except at the end of the road. It is good. The plot, story line and the uke isn't behaving like some stupid bitch and he can handle things by himself which is already an achievement when it comes to bl... As for overrated i would say blood bank, make me bark, a guy like you... Etc
When I first started reading it I was very intrigued by the plot,but it progressed into a story that didn't make sense at parts,the was so much unnecessary drama and all the characters were selfish,annoying and bratty (expect for the mc) there were also some kind of underdeveloped parts.I actually enjoyed blad bank and make me bark (I'm not gonna lie it is way overrated especially with that abrupt ending)
*blood
I see, as I expected you guys have certain expectations to high-rating mangas. Lol, I don't usually think that much, I usually rate a manga in a my heart based on how much I like it. That is what most people do. So the overrating thing may result from that. If one manga is particularly sexy, funny or artistically great. It may get overrated based on how people think despite it falls short of other areas. I actually find all high-rating mangas on this web pretty enjoyable, but once in a while I feel some mangas are rated low.
I mean, it is purely favorism right XD
I do not dislike the way you guys rate mangas though, you guys are the reasons why some great but less known mangas can be valued and appreciated.
Oh my. I actually have kinda similar feeling. The plot at the beginning was rly interesting but later on it indeed kinda started to lack sense at some parts... I was so hooked up with the beginning that I kinda overlooked it but I guess it makes sense since lately I stopped reading it even though I looked up to it so much... I totally didn’t enjoy make me bark tho. It was completely unoriginal and boring... At some points I liked the humor but that was rly all... it didn’t stand out with anything :/ blood bank wasn’t all that bad but it was kinda like... trying to put some actual plot while focusing on BL and I ended up with a filling that both lacked somehow... And the semes behavior annoyed me at some moments... Actually I don’t rly understand what you liked about these :/ they seem incredibly overrated for me... I would give 3/10 for make me bark and maybe 6,5/10 for blood bank... and the ending of the second one was ridiculous... Even tho the webtoon wasn’t all that bad itself...
I guess that’s kinda a compliment or sth so thx xD but don’t misunderstand... I rly think quite a bit of us don’t rate every each manga with high quality, I think we all have themes/genres with which we lack objectivity... Simply after some time you start noticing more, and some patterns too and way more mangas are like “nice but nothing special” (just as this one was for me, tho I’m not saying it’s bad, absolutely). Just you kinda have higher expectations and you start value originality I guess... or sth like that.... that’s just my opinion of course.
Hahahah I think that a 3 is kind of harsh.I haven't rated those manhwas because I know they're not great or anything,I just found them enjoyable.I agree with blood bank to a certain extent,the plot was lacking but I didn't think that the romance was lacking as well (I don't remember any details so I might be wrong).As for make me bark I guess it's because I liked the characters,but I was very disappointed at how it turned out.I definitely wouldn't give make me bark to someone who was looking for a good plot.
Originality is absolutely important but even with repetitive themes if they're executed correctly I still value them more than originality.Something can be original and bad,what's important for me is the development etc
Yeah,you're right.Everyone has a different opinion and that is fine we choose to focus on different aspects of a story.We are not here to critic mangas aftell all,just enjoy them but once in a while it's nice to exchange opinions with others as long as they're willing to understand why something is as great as they think it is (myself included).
*isn't
I know it is not the best, but still wondering why rate so low......