I know that this is an old comment…
I totally agree with your first two points!! But I gotta agree to disagree with the “worthless rating system”
You claim that some readers are being overly generous by rating certain mangas 4-5 starts, but it’s not that they are being generous… it’s because in their own way, they genuinely liked the story. So where as you would rate this as a mid star manga because you didn’t enjoy it, they too can rate the things they like as 4-5 stars…
So there’s no way that this system is worthless, as it is averaging everyone’s opinions, which is what a rating system is supposed to do. I mean I genuinely hated many 4-5 rated manga/manhwas on here but what can I do if I don’t enjoy things they same way as others.. I simply just add my own ratings to the mix.
two notable things:
first, the way that bitch Yuzuki got confronted was satisfying but I wished he got at least punched in the stomach.
the way Haru didn't come immediately to Renji to take his hand was kinda infuriating. he looks like some bitch acting hard to get when he already knew what's the right thing to do yet still hesitated...
after re-reading it, I think this ones a 3 stars.
I also noticed how readers here are so generous to usually rate 4 & 5 stars everytime even when the book is clearly mid. by doing this it somehow made the rating system worthless.