The sibling didn’t treat her “evil” sibling bad. She actually liked her. The “evil” sibling got jealous of her twin and tried to kill her. So yes she was actually evil.
No she wasn't evil. Everyone treated her like shit and since they were twins, she naturally was jealous of her because their treatment was obviously different. If they never treated her like that or just with decency, she would have never felt the need to poison her sister
if you try to murder someone that hasn't done anything wrong to u then yeah your evil
Its circumstantial. If there was no reason or if the cause and effect didn't add up, sure. I would agree but it makes sense given the circumstances. If they didn't treat her vastly different from her twin, she wouldn't have felt resentment towards her. Cause and effect
if you murder an innocent person. yer evil. its that short
You're taking away the complexities of humans but ok. If all she did was make evil decisions than sure but thats not the case
Then*
she isnt evil for hating the people, she only started to be considered evil when she decided to start murdering people who weren't even at fault. it doesn't matter about her complex emotions or situation.
I always have a problem with story that have good mc with evil siblings. If the mc really good and a blessing etc why did they treat their "evil" sibling like they r nobody! Just bcs the parents says so(which is sucks as a parents) it doesn't mean that they can't think by themselves. Everyone need love! Ok there still more thing I want to say but let it's just end here.