beta
8/10
art: clean, consistent, well-proportioned
story: starts off interesting, good mix of cute moments and tension, but once they get together it starts feeling VERY cliche
characters: uke is a little weak and seme does a 180 personality wise, but it's tolerable
sex scenes: quite good
7/10
ART: very clean and pretty, the outfits are also quite attractive. toes the edge of same-face syndrome, especially for characters with similar hairstyles.
STORY: stars off very cute and refreshing but starts to drag once yuyang realizes his feelings. it feels like the author is dragging things out artificially.
CHARACTERS: li huan is a sweetheart, yuyang is more complex but still likeable. the side characters are tolerably interesting.
SEX SCENES: n/a
6/10
ART: juvenile and a mediocre sense of human proportion.
STORY: extremely forgettable. jam-packed with "cute" moments, but i didn't find it compelling at all. the first season was okay, but i was unable to keep reading after that.
CHARACTERS: they are both sweet kids, but much like the art they feel juvenile and flat.
SEX SCENES: i don't remember if there were any, certainly nothing explicit.
6/10
ART: i really did not like the art in this one. again, the artist has no solid grasp of human anatomy, which is extra noticeable when trying to draw "sexy" characters or scenes.
STORY: a very interesting premise and i think it is what stands out the most about this one. i didn't finish it but the pacing was good and i could easily understand the plot.
CHARACTERS: one is forgettable and the other one is rude. not my cup of tea.
SEX SCENES: i don't remember there being any
8/10
ART: the art is beautiful and clean, plus it is full color. however the same-face syndrome is so bad in this one! i could not tell any of the characters apart if it weren't for the haircolor.
STORY: i love fantasy themes and there seems to be interesting world building. there isn't really that much actually going on so far though.
CHARACTERS: decently fleshed out, though the main character does seem a little bland. san is my favorite so far.
SEX SCENES: very good and on the realistic side.
9/10 (may consider moving to top list)
ART: consistent, distinctive and clean, though it's a little cartoony in the face for my taste. if it were a bit more attractive this would be on my top list for sure.
STORY: well paced slice of life style plot with enough drama to keep things compelling but still light-hearted.
CHARACTERS: suuuuper cute. i like how the mains are both straightforward. side characters are also great.
SEX SCENES: very frequent and VERY hot.
5/10
ART: decent, but overly shiny. overall pleasant to look at.
STORY: i could not get far enough into this to comprehend any kind of story beyond the silver-haired one essentially r*ping the black-haired one.
CHARACTERS: one is a r*pist and the other one is supposed to fall in love with him, so definitely not my cup of tea.
SEX SCENES: extremely kinky but again, not enjoyable whatsoever because it's r*pe.
regardless of what happens later, i really cannot recommend this to anyone.
BJ alex